Supreme Court Holds National Book Trust Is 'State' Under Article 12
By Squirrels·
Advertisement
The Supreme Court held that the National Book Trust qualifies as 'State' within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, upholding an earlier view taken by the Delhi High Court. The determination brings the body within the scope of the fundamental rights framework, under which 'State' is defined to include the government and bodies that function as its instrumentalities.
Article 12 is the threshold provision that decides which entities can be held directly accountable for violations of fundamental rights. Courts assess factors such as governmental control, funding and the public character of an organisation's functions when deciding whether a body falls within the definition.
Why it matters
Whether an organisation is 'State' determines the remedies available to those who deal with it, including employees and others affected by its decisions. Rulings that extend the definition widen the set of institutions answerable under the fundamental rights chapter, and are closely watched for how they draw the boundary between public bodies and autonomous entities.
For bodies that receive substantial government funding and perform public functions, the ruling is a reminder that a formal corporate structure does not necessarily place them beyond the reach of the fundamental rights framework. The reasoning will be studied in future disputes over the status of similar institutions.
